Democratic Senate nominee James Webb, challenging Republican Senator George Allen in Virginia, has a new ad coming out which uses videotape of President Reagan complimenting him on his service record in a 1985 speech at the Naval Academy. Former First Lady Nancy Reagan objects to the use of her husband's image in this fashion, and has written Webb to ask him not to run the ad. Bob Lewis of the Associated Press has the story:
Democratic Senate candidate Jim Webb has a television ad ready to air featuring praise from his late boss Ronald Reagan -- and Nancy Reagan called on him Friday to cancel it.
Webb, who was Reagan's Navy secretary before Webb switched to the Democratic Party, uses the ultimate GOP icon to send a sentimental message to conservatives and moderates courted by his Republican opponent, Sen. George Allen. The ad is scheduled to begin airing next week.But a three-paragraph letter from the former first lady's office said the use of footage of Reagan, who died in 2004, is "neither authorized nor appropriate."
Read the rest at the link provided above. There are some federal laws regarding the use of images of Presidents - current or former - but I'm not certain whether they apply to political campaigns. Certainly using Reagan's words in this setting will be misleading - while Reagan did appoint Webb Assistant SecDef and Secretary of the Navy, they did not part on friendly terms.
It is quite likely that using the Reagan image in a political ad for someone he would clearly not be supporting will backfire on the Webb campaign, as the controversy raised by Mrs. Reagan's objections should more than counteract the deceptive effect intended.
UPDATE 1:09 a.m. to add context: Here is portion of the speech which refers to Webb:
In today's Navy, as with the other services, the Reserves are playing an increasingly important role. Who are they? Citizens concerned about the future of this country and determined to do their part. They share their time, energy, and talent to keep America strong, safe, and free.
Sometimes it's hard to find the words to express my heartfelt gratitude for those who serve on active duty and in the Reserves. But it isn't difficult to find the words to explain why they do what they do. It only takes one word -- patriotism. And as Commander in Chief, I am overwhelmed at times by their dedication and courage.I see this every day. We've enlisted the talent of some Naval Academy graduates at the White House. Robert McFarlane, my national security adviser, his deputy, Admiral John Poindexter, graduated in 1959 and 1958 respectively, and I'm proud to note that their sons are following in their footsteps here at the Academy.
One man who sat where you do now and graduated from the Naval Academy in 1968 is another member of our administration -- Assistant Secretary of Defense James Webb, the most decorated member of his class. James' gallantry as a marine officer in Vietnam won him the Navy Cross and other decorations, including two Purple Hearts. James wrote several books about American service men and women. In his book, ``A Sense of Honor,'' he describes the life that you have chosen. He wrote:
``Servicemen are always in motion, in the air at more than the speed of sound, underwater at depths whales could only dream of, on the surface of the water cruising at 30 miles an hour through crashing seas with another ship almost touching theirs . . . replenishing their oil supplies. Or they are on the ground, in the dirt, testing and training weapons that may someday kill others but today may deal them that same irony. The smallest margin of error separates a live man from a dead man. And in war, of course, they are the first and usually the only ones to pay. The President and the Congress may suffer bad news stories. The military man suffers the deaths of his friends, early and often.'' End quote.
I want each of you to know that this President understands and appreciates the job that you will be doing. Your lives are precious. You are putting yourselves in harm's way for America's sake, and I will do everything in my power to make certain the country gives you the tools and equipment you need to do your job and to come home safely.
You can read the entire speech HERE.
UPDATE 4:30 a.m. 9/11: Several sources are telling me that Mrs. Reagan and/or the Reagan Presidential Library have objected to political usage of the Reagan image by campaigns of both parties on several occasions in the past. At present, I have no link or other independent confirmation of that.



Comments (6)
If Ronald Reagan were alive... (Below threshold)1. Posted by Scrapiron | September 10, 2006 1:07 AM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
If Ronald Reagan were alive today he'd take Webb's head off. Of course since there's nothing in the head it wouldn't do much harm. Webb is a loser all the way around and if the people of Va elect him then it is to their shame. Kind of like joining WVa in electing the KKK and dipshi* Rockefeller.
1. Posted by Scrapiron | September 10, 2006 1:07 AM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 10, 2006 01:07
2. Posted by JPTERP | September 10, 2006 8:54 AM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
What's the source for the "bad terms" Reagan and Webb break-up? I keep hearing this on partisan conservative blogs, but my understanding of the historical record is otherwise. At least in Reagan's letter to Webb in the Reagan archives, there's is no indication of a "bad terms" break-up.
"Dear Jim:
It is with regret that I accept your resignation as Secretary of the Navy, effective February 22, 1988.
During the past four years, you have served our country with honor and courage, just as you have throughout your distinguished career. As my first Assistant Secretary of Defense for Reserve Affairs, you played a major role in revitalizing the reserve components of our Armed Forces. You were instrumental in restoring confidence and pride in one of our most noble national traditions -- the concept of the American citizen-soldier.
Since taking the helm a year ago as Secretary of the Navy, you continued to press forward the highest standards of excellence throughout the Navy and Marine Corps. From the most remote outposts to the lecture halls of Annapolis, your commitment to the quality of our military capability and the well-being of our men and women in uniform has been undivided.
As your service to this Administration comes to a close, I want to thank you for the selflessness and loyalty that you have always personified. In the end, it is these qualities that will ensure that freedom endures in this generation and in every generation to come.
Godspeed in all your endeavors.
Sincerely,
Ronald Reagan
February 23, 1988
Source:
http://www.reagan.utexas.edu/archives/speeches/1988/022388b.htm
2. Posted by JPTERP | September 10, 2006 8:54 AM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 10, 2006 08:54
3. Posted by Teddy Goodson | September 10, 2006 11:16 PM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Concerning the Webb ad: there is absolutely nothing negative in the ad. Ed Meese, who has a few Iran Contra skeletons in his own closet, wrote what purports to be Miss Nancy's letter, calling the ad "negative." He is wrong, and this leads me to suspect Mrs. Reagan never saw the ad, knows nothing about it, except what Meese and Allen may (finally) have told her.
The Reagan speech is public record, nothing is made up, no photoshopping was done (unlike so many Republicans' ads I have seen). Frankly, I believe the ad is completely A-okay and those reporters who pretend it will redound to Mr. Webb's discredit are only mouthing Republican talking points, hoping if they repeat it often enough it will become so. Do you suppose Mrs. Reagan has given a written permission slip to every one of those other candidates who keep trotting out the Great Republican Icon to prop up their own campaigns? George Allen has done so on his web site, by the way.
This too shall pass, folks. Get ready to deal with a tsunami of sludge from the desperate Allen campaign, none of which will be factual and all of which will be negative.
3. Posted by Teddy Goodson | September 10, 2006 11:16 PM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 10, 2006 23:16
4. Posted by Jim Addison | September 11, 2006 12:50 AM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Reagan wrote glowing exit letters for virtually everyone who ever worked for him - including several who left under indictment or investigation. He was a nice, classy guy. He would never stoop to getting into a public pissing match with someone, expecially some low-level schmuck like Webb, who began trashing Reagan as he walked out the door and continued at least until GWB was elected. Then he would say something nice about Reagan occasionally so he could compare Bush unfavorably.
I do see how these concepts would be entirely foreign to people who would support the likes of Webb, though.
No, Mrs. Reagan hasn't objected to the many other uses of the President's image and words by candidates of both parties. That's because the others who attempted to latch onto the Reagan legacy hadn't spent decades slandering him. The ad carries an implied endorsement, which is completely misleading.
That the elderly widow would suddenly object to this ad, joined by the old friend of RR, Ed Meese, might give you an indication of what the Gipper's private opinion of Webb was.
4. Posted by Jim Addison | September 11, 2006 12:50 AM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 11, 2006 00:50
5. Posted by Jim Addison | September 11, 2006 4:38 AM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
As I note in the update to the stem post, I have heard from more than one source that Nancy Reagan and/or the Reagan Library has regularly objected to the use of the President's image or video in campaign ads from both parties.
If this turns out to be true, I amend the preceding assertion and acknowledge error. There certainly have been many uses of the Reagan image which were not protested, though, in any event.
5. Posted by Jim Addison | September 11, 2006 4:38 AM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 11, 2006 04:38
6. Posted by Michael Coats | September 17, 2006 10:27 PM | Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
OK....I know how little facts mean to the new era Karl Rove type of republican Jim, but where did you get the idea that Webb resigned because he wanted to CUT the military??
Just asking, because unlike most people in the present administration, (and more than likely most of you neocons who post here), I actually served in the military during the period that Webb was the secnav....and that ain't the way I remember it.
But I was not surprised that you boys decided to attack Webb. I mean he was a Naval Acadamy grad, served as a Marine in Vietnam, and was awarded the Navy Cross for bravery in combat among other awards. I KNOW how you neocon types hate this type of person....hell...he probably doesn't even have a bumper sticker on his car saying "support the troops".
6. Posted by Michael Coats | September 17, 2006 10:27 PM |
Score: 0 (0 votes cast)
Posted on September 17, 2006 22:27